Skip to:

Trainer Comparison

Statistics by Year:
Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 8 17 2.13 0 1 3 0% 23.53% $28,950 $1,703 $3,619 0 0
Carole Donaldson 5 16 3.2 2 2 3 12.5% 43.75% $26,670 $1,667 $5,334 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 9 17 1.89 2 1 4 11.76% 41.18% $63,600 $3,741 $7,067 0 0
Carole Donaldson 8 30 3.75 5 9 4 16.67% 60% $59,098 $1,970 $7,387 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 8 22 2.75 3 2 2 13.64% 31.82% $86,100 $3,914 $10,763 0 0
Carole Donaldson 11 30 2.73 2 3 6 6.67% 36.67% $56,658 $1,889 $5,151 1 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 3 12 4 1 0 3 8.33% 33.33% $51,950 $4,329 $17,317 0 0
Carole Donaldson 11 27 2.45 4 4 2 14.81% 37.04% $30,870 $1,143 $2,806 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 9 27 3 3 3 5 11.11% 40.74% $78,300 $2,900 $8,700 0 0
Carole Donaldson 8 28 3.5 5 2 3 17.86% 35.71% $29,518 $1,054 $3,690 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 10 34 3.4 3 1 4 8.82% 23.53% $68,470 $2,014 $6,847 0 0
Carole Donaldson 5 19 3.8 4 5 4 21.05% 68.42% $49,586 $2,610 $9,917 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 20 49 2.45 4 4 7 8.16% 30.61% $249,285 $5,087 $12,464 0 0
Carole Donaldson 7 26 3.71 3 1 8 11.54% 46.15% $22,824 $878 $3,261 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 19 48 2.53 6 6 6 12.5% 37.5% $293,831 $6,121 $15,465 1 0
Carole Donaldson 7 37 5.29 10 5 2 27.03% 45.95% $56,702 $1,532 $8,100 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 21 62 2.95 7 7 9 11.29% 37.1% $206,840 $3,336 $9,850 0 0
Carole Donaldson 8 46 5.75 6 10 4 13.04% 43.48% $47,017 $1,022 $5,877 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 25 71 2.84 6 3 11 8.45% 28.17% $201,600 $2,839 $8,064 0 0
Carole Donaldson 12 54 4.5 6 7 12 11.11% 46.3% $57,077 $1,057 $4,756 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 24 71 2.96 8 10 14 11.27% 45.07% $374,575 $5,276 $15,607 1 0
Carole Donaldson 7 22 3.14 4 3 5 18.18% 54.55% $24,945 $1,134 $3,564 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 27 92 3.41 14 15 16 15.22% 48.91% $745,825 $8,107 $27,623 3 0
Carole Donaldson 9 57 6.33 6 6 11 10.53% 40.35% $38,999 $684 $4,333 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 30 89 2.97 15 12 8 16.85% 39.33% $525,343 $5,903 $17,511 1 0
Carole Donaldson 10 50 5 8 7 8 16% 46% $41,371 $827 $4,137 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 22 59 2.68 11 13 7 18.64% 52.54% $470,300 $7,971 $21,377 2 0
Carole Donaldson 9 33 3.67 4 4 5 12.12% 39.39% $28,642 $868 $3,182 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 17 59 3.47 14 12 8 23.73% 57.63% $270,690 $4,588 $15,923 0 0
Carole Donaldson 11 57 5.18 6 9 6 10.53% 36.84% $93,203 $1,635 $8,473 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
Richard L. Valentine 16 51 3.19 7 9 5 13.73% 41.18% $115,678 $2,268 $7,230 0 0
Carole Donaldson 8 33 4.13 7 5 3 21.21% 45.45% $43,153 $1,308 $5,394 0 0