Skip to:

Trainer Comparison

Statistics by Year:
Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Elly Rutherford 4 20 5 4 3 5 20% 60% $23,820 $1,191 $5,955 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Elly Rutherford 2 13 6.5 1 2 2 7.69% 38.46% $11,351 $873 $5,676 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 7 24 3.43 1 5 0 4.17% 25% $99,453 $4,144 $14,208 0 0
Elly Rutherford 3 16 5.33 2 2 3 12.5% 43.75% $15,215 $951 $5,072 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 14 54 3.86 3 8 7 5.56% 33.33% $326,692 $6,050 $23,335 0 0
Elly Rutherford 5 29 5.8 5 4 5 17.24% 48.28% $24,625 $849 $4,925 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 15 49 3.27 4 4 10 8.16% 36.73% $213,841 $4,364 $14,256 0 0
Elly Rutherford 4 23 5.75 5 5 2 21.74% 52.17% $14,941 $650 $3,735 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 17 100 5.88 9 8 8 9% 25% $364,281 $3,643 $21,428 0 0
Elly Rutherford 2 7 3.5 3 0 1 42.86% 57.14% $5,461 $780 $2,731 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 26 126 4.85 17 7 26 13.49% 39.68% $780,549 $6,195 $30,021 0 0
Elly Rutherford 4 8 2 2 0 2 25% 50% $5,257 $657 $1,314 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 27 95 3.52 11 10 10 11.58% 32.63% $364,919 $3,841 $13,516 0 0
Elly Rutherford 7 20 2.86 5 7 0 25% 60% $16,689 $834 $2,384 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 29 119 4.1 10 12 13 8.4% 29.41% $350,608 $2,946 $12,090 0 0
Elly Rutherford 5 15 3 1 7 3 6.67% 73.33% $10,351 $690 $2,070 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 34 145 4.26 19 13 20 13.1% 35.86% $496,236 $3,422 $14,595 0 0
Elly Rutherford 2 8 4 1 0 0 12.5% 12.5% $2,158 $270 $1,079 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 25 131 5.24 18 17 15 13.74% 38.17% $685,189 $5,230 $27,408 1 2
Elly Rutherford 5 29 5.8 4 4 7 13.79% 51.72% $24,096 $831 $4,819 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 24 97 4.04 16 14 14 16.49% 45.36% $635,102 $6,547 $26,463 0 2
Elly Rutherford 4 29 7.25 1 3 5 3.45% 31.03% $19,217 $663 $4,804 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 19 111 5.84 19 13 17 17.12% 44.14% $555,054 $5,000 $29,213 0 0
Elly Rutherford 4 29 7.25 5 4 4 17.24% 44.83% $47,817 $1,649 $11,954 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 20 84 4.2 13 3 8 15.48% 28.57% $307,919 $3,666 $15,396 0 0
Elly Rutherford 5 33 6.6 5 5 5 15.15% 45.45% $35,953 $1,089 $7,191 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 24 134 5.58 18 14 19 13.43% 38.06% $543,959 $4,059 $22,665 0 2
Elly Rutherford 7 34 4.86 3 5 4 8.82% 35.29% $23,797 $700 $3,400 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 21 109 5.19 18 15 16 16.51% 44.95% $610,352 $5,600 $29,064 0 4
Elly Rutherford 4 23 5.75 2 4 4 8.7% 43.48% $32,572 $1,416 $8,143 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 33 155 4.7 13 19 15 8.39% 30.32% $309,489 $1,997 $9,378 0 0
Elly Rutherford 1 2 2 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 29 141 4.86 14 17 25 9.93% 39.72% $420,824 $2,985 $14,511 0 1
Elly Rutherford 7 29 4.14 1 0 5 3.45% 20.69% $12,422 $428 $1,775 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 55 247 4.49 22 28 30 8.91% 32.39% $715,364 $2,896 $13,007 0 2
Elly Rutherford 11 57 5.18 3 8 5 5.26% 28.07% $39,707 $697 $3,610 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 60 258 4.3 34 36 39 13.18% 42.25% $1,141,277 $4,424 $19,021 0 2
Elly Rutherford 8 32 4 1 5 4 3.13% 31.25% $13,936 $436 $1,742 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 67 295 4.4 28 38 39 9.49% 35.59% $1,185,953 $4,020 $17,701 1 3
Elly Rutherford 7 51 7.29 5 8 7 9.8% 39.22% $37,528 $736 $5,361 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 68 260 3.82 35 27 44 13.46% 40.77% $1,347,291 $5,182 $19,813 3 4
Elly Rutherford 16 96 6 6 13 10 6.25% 30.21% $96,850 $1,009 $6,053 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 56 282 5.04 40 30 32 14.18% 36.17% $1,148,462 $4,073 $20,508 1 6
Elly Rutherford 14 83 5.93 10 12 14 12.05% 43.37% $111,276 $1,341 $7,948 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 68 311 4.57 42 40 39 13.5% 38.91% $1,313,178 $4,222 $19,311 0 2
Elly Rutherford 10 45 4.5 5 5 6 11.11% 35.56% $43,138 $959 $4,314 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 72 266 3.69 40 41 36 15.04% 43.98% $1,356,016 $5,098 $18,834 3 4
Elly Rutherford 5 24 4.8 2 4 2 8.33% 33.33% $15,073 $628 $3,015 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 61 290 4.75 33 46 37 11.38% 40% $1,477,188 $5,094 $24,216 1 4
Elly Rutherford 6 16 2.67 1 1 2 6.25% 25% $5,395 $337 $899 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 69 312 4.52 52 45 42 16.67% 44.55% $1,216,437 $3,899 $17,630 0 4
Elly Rutherford 2 5 2.5 1 0 0 20% 20% $2,614 $523 $1,307 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 70 309 4.41 50 43 37 16.18% 42.07% $1,063,264 $3,441 $15,189 0 5
Elly Rutherford 5 38 7.6 2 8 6 5.26% 42.11% $18,386 $484 $3,677 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 81 403 4.98 57 60 46 14.14% 40.45% $1,269,672 $3,151 $15,675 0 0
Elly Rutherford 15 68 4.53 9 3 10 13.24% 32.35% $41,487 $610 $2,766 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 78 340 4.36 51 40 54 15% 42.65% $1,024,295 $3,013 $13,132 1 3
Elly Rutherford 16 88 5.5 21 11 7 23.86% 44.32% $93,414 $1,062 $5,838 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 73 371 5.08 44 52 44 11.86% 37.74% $768,943 $2,073 $10,533 0 0
Elly Rutherford 13 67 5.15 16 17 8 23.88% 61.19% $76,813 $1,146 $5,909 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 74 376 5.08 63 50 50 16.76% 43.35% $893,839 $2,377 $12,079 0 0
Elly Rutherford 9 47 5.22 7 7 6 14.89% 42.55% $28,821 $613 $3,202 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 64 294 4.59 49 40 33 16.67% 41.5% $729,386 $2,481 $11,397 0 0
Elly Rutherford 3 37 12.33 9 4 2 24.32% 40.54% $26,728 $722 $8,909 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 66 345 5.23 43 57 31 12.46% 37.97% $603,703 $1,750 $9,147 0 0
Elly Rutherford 2 5 2.5 1 1 0 20% 40% $2,546 $509 $1,273 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,028
David R. Vance 46 247 5.37 32 27 28 12.96% 35.22% $329,287 $1,333 $7,158 0 0
Elly Rutherford 1 1 1 0 0 1 0% 100% $410 $410 $410 0 0