Skip to:

OwnerView is growing. Help introduce others to ownership.
Visit the
New Site

Trainer Comparison

Statistics by Year:
Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 48 166 3.46 41 25 28 24.7% 56.63% $947,396 $5,707 $19,737 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 3 11 3.67 0 2 2 0% 36.36% $43,820 $3,984 $14,607 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 85 382 4.49 57 54 55 14.92% 43.46% $1,715,977 $4,492 $20,188 0 5
Melanie W. McDonald 2 19 9.5 0 3 4 0% 36.84% $62,350 $3,282 $31,175 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 111 480 4.32 77 72 74 16.04% 46.46% $2,101,894 $4,379 $18,936 0 5
Melanie W. McDonald 8 33 4.13 3 4 3 9.09% 30.3% $48,100 $1,458 $6,013 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 118 543 4.6 93 90 73 17.13% 47.15% $2,052,920 $3,781 $17,398 0 2
Melanie W. McDonald 7 42 6 2 2 6 4.76% 23.81% $57,244 $1,363 $8,178 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 117 481 4.11 90 54 73 18.71% 45.11% $2,087,269 $4,339 $17,840 0 3
Melanie W. McDonald 8 43 5.38 2 4 1 4.65% 16.28% $57,537 $1,338 $7,192 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 90 377 4.19 81 49 52 21.49% 48.28% $1,817,196 $4,820 $20,191 0 2
Melanie W. McDonald 7 33 4.71 2 4 6 6.06% 36.36% $38,760 $1,175 $5,537 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 82 337 4.11 37 43 38 10.98% 35.01% $862,662 $2,560 $10,520 0 1
Melanie W. McDonald 3 10 3.33 1 0 1 10% 20% $10,050 $1,005 $3,350 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 71 243 3.42 40 39 25 16.46% 42.8% $811,544 $3,340 $11,430 0 1
Melanie W. McDonald 7 35 5 1 4 6 2.86% 31.43% $31,738 $907 $4,534 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 100 310 3.1 37 40 34 11.94% 35.81% $670,082 $2,162 $6,701 0 1
Melanie W. McDonald 9 60 6.67 1 7 5 1.67% 21.67% $45,910 $765 $5,101 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 165 593 3.59 101 83 57 17.03% 40.64% $2,056,901 $3,469 $12,466 0 2
Melanie W. McDonald 9 68 7.56 6 13 9 8.82% 41.18% $78,010 $1,147 $8,668 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 122 472 3.87 69 56 58 14.62% 38.77% $2,044,432 $4,331 $16,758 2 7
Melanie W. McDonald 6 31 5.17 1 5 4 3.23% 32.26% $30,345 $979 $5,058 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 130 459 3.53 59 57 60 12.85% 38.34% $1,136,603 $2,476 $8,743 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 6 28 4.67 0 3 2 0% 17.86% $16,807 $600 $2,801 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 112 340 3.04 81 50 37 23.82% 49.41% $1,201,829 $3,535 $10,731 0 1
Melanie W. McDonald 6 24 4 1 1 5 4.17% 29.17% $30,842 $1,285 $5,140 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 78 294 3.77 32 35 33 10.88% 34.01% $417,286 $1,419 $5,350 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 4 23 5.75 3 3 0 13.04% 26.09% $43,810 $1,905 $10,953 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 111 408 3.68 56 73 56 13.73% 45.34% $980,498 $2,403 $8,833 0 1
Melanie W. McDonald 4 11 2.75 0 2 1 0% 27.27% $6,690 $608 $1,673 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 69 261 3.78 51 37 37 19.54% 47.89% $807,790 $3,095 $11,707 0 2
Melanie W. McDonald 3 15 5 1 2 2 6.67% 33.33% $15,698 $1,047 $5,233 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 69 334 4.84 39 47 58 11.68% 43.11% $501,475 $1,501 $7,268 0 1
Melanie W. McDonald 4 26 6.5 2 6 4 7.69% 46.15% $41,378 $1,591 $10,345 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 49 177 3.61 37 19 25 20.9% 45.76% $343,948 $1,943 $7,019 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 7 33 4.71 2 3 7 6.06% 36.36% $30,182 $915 $4,312 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 40 118 2.95 16 19 13 13.56% 40.68% $203,009 $1,720 $5,075 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 6 44 7.33 2 3 6 4.55% 25% $51,704 $1,175 $8,617 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 13 36 2.77 5 3 6 13.89% 38.89% $38,960 $1,082 $2,997 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 7 34 4.86 0 0 3 0% 8.82% $15,488 $456 $2,213 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 10 25 2.5 1 4 2 4% 28% $13,190 $528 $1,319 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 8 33 4.13 1 0 1 3.03% 6.06% $19,725 $598 $2,466 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 3 23 7.67 0 1 5 0% 26.09% $15,554 $676 $5,185 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 8 39 4.88 2 2 3 5.13% 17.95% $31,006 $795 $3,876 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 2 9 4.5 0 1 0 0% 11.11% $1,368 $152 $684 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 8 56 7 1 5 7 1.79% 23.21% $32,071 $573 $4,009 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 3 8 2.67 0 1 1 0% 25% $2,350 $294 $783 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 10 57 5.7 3 3 1 5.26% 12.28% $30,024 $527 $3,002 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 11 84 7.64 6 16 9 7.14% 36.9% $84,900 $1,011 $7,718 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 9 24 2.67 1 4 1 4.17% 25% $8,055 $336 $895 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 15 109 7.27 8 8 9 7.34% 22.94% $75,129 $689 $5,009 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 35 138 3.94 10 10 13 7.25% 23.91% $63,073 $457 $1,802 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 15 87 5.8 3 2 5 3.45% 11.49% $47,004 $540 $3,134 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 37 136 3.68 12 18 13 8.82% 31.62% $102,804 $756 $2,778 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 14 94 6.71 6 11 10 6.38% 28.72% $183,963 $1,957 $13,140 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 35 134 3.83 18 15 15 13.43% 35.82% $65,524 $489 $1,872 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 16 117 7.31 10 16 16 8.55% 35.9% $175,022 $1,496 $10,939 0 1

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 47 168 3.57 20 14 24 11.9% 34.52% $59,865 $356 $1,274 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 16 88 5.5 7 6 11 7.95% 27.27% $58,048 $660 $3,628 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 16 42 2.63 4 3 5 9.52% 28.57% $14,311 $341 $894 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 11 86 7.82 3 12 17 3.49% 37.21% $40,126 $467 $3,648 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 4 11 2.75 0 0 1 0% 9.09% $662 $60 $166 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 11 83 7.55 5 7 6 6.02% 21.69% $26,094 $314 $2,372 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 16 65 4.06 5 7 9 7.69% 32.31% $39,431 $607 $2,464 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 13 57 4.38 3 3 5 5.26% 19.3% $10,622 $186 $817 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 4 13.53% 40.55% $5,513 $22,031
J. R. Caldwell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% $0 $0 $0 0 0
Melanie W. McDonald 19 89 4.68 7 12 9 7.87% 31.46% $32,849 $369 $1,729 0 0