Skip to:

Trainer Comparison

Statistics by Year:
Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 2 3 1.5 0 0 0 0% 0% $7,789 $2,596 $3,895 0 0
Charlie Livers 3 17 5.67 7 2 2 41.18% 64.71% $70,677 $4,157 $23,559 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 3 28 9.33 3 3 1 10.71% 25% $147,207 $5,257 $49,069 0 0
Charlie Livers 8 38 4.75 4 1 5 10.53% 26.32% $87,825 $2,311 $10,978 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 4 13 3.25 0 4 2 0% 46.15% $37,074 $2,852 $9,269 0 0
Charlie Livers 11 46 4.18 2 2 4 4.35% 17.39% $77,868 $1,693 $7,079 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 3 15 5 1 0 1 6.67% 13.33% $38,521 $2,568 $12,840 0 0
Charlie Livers 12 70 5.83 5 9 10 7.14% 34.29% $191,639 $2,738 $15,970 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 4 14 3.5 0 0 0 0% 0% $12,091 $864 $3,023 0 0
Charlie Livers 9 49 5.44 4 4 5 8.16% 26.53% $53,863 $1,099 $5,985 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 6 21 3.5 2 1 0 9.52% 14.29% $120,960 $5,760 $20,160 0 0
Charlie Livers 16 54 3.38 6 5 5 11.11% 29.63% $80,722 $1,495 $5,045 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 9 45 5 5 1 3 11.11% 20% $115,104 $2,558 $12,789 0 0
Charlie Livers 11 55 5 4 9 9 7.27% 40% $48,291 $878 $4,390 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 8 46 5.75 2 2 6 4.35% 21.74% $97,277 $2,115 $12,160 0 0
Charlie Livers 8 24 3 0 1 1 0% 8.33% $4,863 $203 $608 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 12 56 4.67 4 8 6 7.14% 32.14% $207,724 $3,709 $17,310 0 0
Charlie Livers 4 17 4.25 2 2 2 11.76% 35.29% $12,547 $738 $3,137 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 13 59 4.54 6 8 6 10.17% 33.9% $243,820 $4,133 $18,755 0 0
Charlie Livers 6 21 3.5 2 1 4 9.52% 33.33% $15,420 $734 $2,570 0 0

Name Starters Starts Starts/
Starter 		1st 2nd 3rd Win % % 1st, 2nd or 3rd Earned Avg Earnings per Start Avg Earnings Per Starter Graded Stakes Win All Black-Type Win
2025 National Trainer Avg. 3.31 13.64% 40.9% $5,415 $17,925
Gary G. Hartlage 27 99 3.67 6 14 7 6.06% 27.27% $329,948 $3,333 $12,220 0 0
Charlie Livers 3 5 1.67 1 1 1 20% 60% $9,160 $1,832 $3,053 0 0