Rhetorical picks up second Grade 1 victory in Saturday’s Old Forester Bourbon Turf Classic at Churchill Downs. Ashley Phillips/Coady Media.
By Paul Halloran
Will Walden wasn’t planning on entering Rhetorical in the Grade 1 Old Forester Bourbon Turf Classic on Saturday’s Kentucky Derby undercard at Churchill Downs. The New York-bred gelding had run three weeks prior in the Makers Mark Mile at Keeneland and finished third, coming off a five-month layoff since running fourth in the Breeders’ Cup Mile at Del Mar.
But when Walden got a look at who was nominated for the Turf Classic and who was committed to run, he called an audible.
Good call.
Under Irad Ortiz Jr., Rhetorical led every step of the way in a 3 1/4-length victory, giving Walden his second Grade 1 win. The $833,280 winner’s share gave him $1,806,730 in career earnings, 14th all-time among New York-breds. He has won six times in nine starts.
“This really wasn’t part of the plan, but you have to keep everybody ready in the barn at all times for when opportunity strikes,” Walden said. “What do they say, better be prepared for an opportunity that you don’t have than not be prepared for one you do. He was doing really, really well.”
Rhetorical, a 4-year-old gelding by Not This Time, was bred by Mallory and Karen Mort and foaled at Marlene Brody’s Gallagher’s Stud in Ghent, where Mallory Mort has worked since 1979 and managed the farm operation since 2005. He was a $320,000 purchase at the 2022 Saratoga New York-bred yearling sale.
He broke his maiden at first asking for Siena Farm and WinStar Farm, and was bought by Gary Barber, Everett Dobson’s Cheyenne Stable and Adam Wachtel’s Wachtel Stable after his third career start. One of three winning foals out of the Distorted Humor mare Sheet Humor, Rhetorical is a half-brother to $1.4 million-earner Sterling Silver, who was also bred by the Morts.
After winning his first stakes in the West Point at Saratoga last August, Rhetorical gave Walden his first Grade 1 by taking the Coolmore Turf Mile at Keeneland, earning him a berth in the Breeders’ Cup, where he was leading at the stretch call before finishing fourth.
In the Makers Mark Mile against a stacked field – “like the Breeders’ Cup Mile in April,” Walden said – Rhetorical did not get to the lead, never looked comfortable and finished 1 1/4 lengths behind Zulu Kingdom, who led gate to wire. Walden expected a different type of race Saturday and he got it.
“He breaks really well. He’s always had such a good turn of foot out of the gate,” Walden said. “I told Irad that I know (Corruption) is going to go, but if you outbreak him, take it over. I’ve always felt deep down inside that this horse would just shut off if he got the lead and he did. He’s always been behind horses, always been stalking and been on the bit and wasting that late turn of foot.”
Rhetorical covered the 1 1/8 miles in a stakes record 1:45.96, including a final furlong in :11:67. Make Me King closed for second and Corruption, who did not show speed, finished third.
“He bounced out of that last race and was training like a wild horse,” Walden said. “He’s just a good horse.”
Rhetorical’s victory also marked the second straight year a New York-bred won the Turf Classic, following Spirit of St Louis’ triumph in 2025.
The post Rhetorical adds Grade 1 Old Forester Bourbon Turf Classic to glistening resume appeared first on New York Thoroughbred Breeders, Inc. News.